Religion
The particular religious and philosophical beliefs held by a minority group are often what distinguishes them from the majority. It is therefore vital that the rights relating to religion and spirituality are protected in both law and fact. They include the right to freedom of conscience, thought and religion; the right to profess or not to profess to a religion; the right to change religion and protection against coercion to change religion; the right to manifest religion; and finally, the right of parents to have their children educated in line with their particular beliefs and convictions. However, the practice of forced assimilation still occurs in countries in which there is a dominant majority religion.
According to obligations set out in international treaties, states must allow groups and not just individuals the opportunity to practice and manifest their religious beliefs. Majority religious groups should be afforded no preferential treatment by governments, even if they are the recognised state religion. Although the right to manifest one’s beliefs is not an absolute right, any restrictions imposed by the state must be prescribed by law, necessary in a democratic society and for the purpose of serving the public. Therefore, no state should restrict this right just because the religion in question is not the recognised state religion, or because of differing beliefs.
One particular right allows parents to withdraw their children from particular classes if they do not feel the teachings are in line with their own religious and moral convictions. This can be crucial for minority groups, as state education may reflect the views of the majority religion, possibly to the detriment of other religious groups.
Instruments protecting the right to freedom of religion
International instruments:
- Article 18, Universal Declaration of Human Rights
- Article 18, International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights
- General Comment No. 22 on Article 18 (The Right to Freedom of Thought, Conscience and Religion), Human Rights Committee
- Article 12, International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of Their Families
- UN Declaration on the Rights of Persons Belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities
- Article 6, Resolution 36/55 Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief, General Assembly
Regional instruments:
- Article 8, African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights
- Article 12 and 13, American Convention on Human Rights
- Articles III and XXIII, American Declaration of the Rights and Duties of Man
- Articles 9 and 14, European Convention on Human Rights
- Articles 10, 14, 21 and 22, Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union
Relevant jurisprudence
International cases:
- Malakhobsky and Pikul v Belarus, Human Rights Committee, 2003
- Hudoyberganova v Uzbekistan, Human Rights Committee, 2000
Regional cases:
- Jehovah’s Witnesses of Moscow v Russia, European Court of Human Rights, 2010
- Refah Partisi and Others v Turkey, European Court of Human Rights, 2001
- Free Legal Assistance Group and Others v Zaire, African Commission of Human and People’s Rights, 2000
- Cha’are Shalom Ve Tsedek v France, European Court of Human Rights, 1999
- Manoussakis and Others v Greece, European Court of Human Rights, 1996
- Valsamis v Greece, European Court of Human Rights 1995
- Wingrove v UK, European Court of Human Rights, 1993
Domestic cases:
- R v Headteachers of Y School, United Kingdom High Court, 2006
- Wittmann v Deutscheer Schulverein, Pretoria and Others, High Court of South Africa, 1998
Photo: A man stands outside a Catholic church in Peshawar, June 2009. Credit: Jared Ferrie.
Share this content
Related content
- Pakistan must honour its commitment to end discrimination against religious minorities
- MRG urges the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief to address violations of the economic and social rights of religious minorities
- UPR of Thailand: MRG & partners urge the government to withdraw emergency laws affecting minorities
- MRG reacts to the report of the UN Freedom of Religion or Belief expert on religious minorities in conflict
- HRC37 – SR on Freedom of religion and belief: MRG’s reaction to the Special Rapporteur’s study on the relationship between states and religions
- Sri Lanka: MRG’s reaction to the report of the OHCHR Investigation on Sri Lanka (OISL)
- Iraq: MRG’s call for a stronger engagement of the UN Human Rights Council
- Belize: Advocating Maya people’s rights to land
- Bosnia and Herzegovina: Bosniak barred from running for Presidency
- Bosnia and Herzegovina: Ensuring the political participation of minorities
- Botswana: Tribal recognition and equality for the Wayeyi
- Burundi: Protecting Batwa land rights
- Chagos Islands: The Right of Return for the Chagossians
- Chile: Mapuche and the right to non-discrimination and equality
- Democratic Republic of Congo: Protecting Batwa land rights
- African Commission of Human and Peoples’ Rights v Kenya (the ‘Ogiek case’)
- Mauritania: Challenging slavery of Haratine Women and Children
- The Inter-American Court of Human Rights Issues Landmark Judgment in Indigenous Rights Case
- Working together to eradicate statelessness in the Dominican Republic
- “Land grabbing” in Africa: An emerging legal framework highlights a lack of accountability for the UK’s role in the violation of land rights
- Europe: Minorities are protected, but by whom?
- Social media: the new frontline in the fight against hate speech
- European Court of Human Rights upholds the ban on Hungarian Guard
- The ICC at 10 Years: Crises of Cooperation, Capacity and Legitimacy
- UN Human Rights Chief: Speech laws must strike balance
- A Pakistani Baha’i’s story
- UK Parliamentary Recognition of Kurdish Genocide in Iraq: What This Means for Minority Groups Today
- Tunisia: achieving equality through legal means and lawyers’ support
- Preventing evictions from the Mau Forest of Kenya
- Exposing a slave society
- Opening the Kartarpur Corridor is a symbol of peace and respect between religions and deserves applause, says MRG
- MRG welcomes decision to uphold blasphemy acquittal of Asia Bibi
- MRG dismayed by recent court decisions concerning slavery in Mauritania
- MRGI welcomes Pakistani supreme court decision to overturn death sentence against Asia Bibi
- Kenyan government Task Force to implement African Court’s Ogiek judgment deeply flawed, MRG and OPDP say
- Minority Rights Group International Legal Director highly commended in prestigious law awards
- Compulsory purchase of Seven Sisters market vital to culture of London’s Latin American community, should not go ahead, says MRG
- African Court releases unanimous decision of judges on Ogiek land case – full judgment coming soon
- Mauritanie: La décision de l’organe Africain sur les Droits de l’Enfant de statuer sur une affaire d’esclavage représente une « lueur d’espoir », disent les organisations de lutte contre l’esclavage
- Međunarodna grupa za prava manjina (MRG) ukazuje na nepostupanje Bosne i Hercegovine po presudi protiv diskriminacije donešene od strane najvišeg Evropskog suda za ljudska prava
- By turning down bill against forced conversion, Pakistan fails to address human rights violations
- Pakistan blasphemy law targets minorities and should be repealed – MRG
- Iran and Iraq: Strengthening human rights defenders organisations working with vulnerable civilians
- Iraq and Pakistan: promoting religious equality for inclusive development
- Supporting Religious Pluralism and Respect for Freedom of Religion or Belief across South Asia (SAC)
- South Asia: Protecting and promoting freedom of religion or belief
- Egypt: Challenging discrimination against religious minorities
- Bosnia and Herzegovina: Supporting minority victims of discrimination accessing their human rights
- Egypt: Challenging discrimination against religious minorities
- Endorois Welfare Council legal and capacity-building project evaluation
- Combating Discrimination and Promoting Minority Rights in Turkey
- Legal Cases programme
- Towards an anti-discrimination law: strategies and opportunities in Iran
- Equality and justice on the sidelines: Comparative report on discrimination against Roma and their access to justice in Slovakia and Slovenia
- In the name of security – Human rights violations under Iran’s national security laws
- Mainstreaming a Minority Rights Based Approach to Refugee and Migrant Communities in Europe
- Confronting intolerance: Continued violations against religious minorities in Sri Lanka
- Under threat: The challenges facing religious minorities in Bangladesh
- Guidance: Exhausting domestic remedies under the African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights
- Minority Rights in the Russian Federation – Legal Framework Review
- Collateral Damage of the Dayton Peace Agreement: Discrimination Against Minorities in Bosnia and Herzegovina, Twenty Years On
- Still invisible – the stigmatization of Shi’a and other religious minorities in Saudi Arabia